Catalina Historical SocietyIsland History Map

Guide · Updated October 2026

Why Are There Bison on Catalina Island?

Catalina Island’s bison began as a film-related import, not as native wildlife. In 1924, bison were brought to the island for possible use in a Western. The animals remained after filming plans ended, and their descendants became a long-running part of Catalina’s story. The exact film they were meant for—and even the number that first arrived—remain disputed.6,7,8,9

A herd brought for a movie

The most familiar explanation is that American bison were shipped to Catalina Island in 1924 to appear in a film based on a Zane Grey story. Accounts most often name The Vanishing American or The Thundering Herd. The animals were associated with the Lasky Film Company, and contemporary reports described them being taken by boat to Catalina Harbor and moved to grazing land near the island’s western end.6,7,8

The starting number is not consistent across accounts. Several sources say 14 bison arrived, while others report 15, 16, or 12. The discrepancy may reflect different reports or counts, so it is safest to say that a small group was brought to the island rather than settle on a precise figure.5,6,7,8,9,10

Which film were they meant for?

The film story is also uncertain. The commonly repeated version links the bison to The Vanishing American, but the 1925 film has no bison scenes. Some accounts instead connect the animals to The Thundering Herd, another Zane Grey adaptation. A 1938 newspaper account said a stampede scene was filmed on Catalina, while a 1925 report placed filming in Yellowstone. The film reels are missing, so that connection cannot be confirmed.6,7,8,9,10

The best-supported explanation is therefore modest: the bison were brought for a possible Western film use, but there is no clear evidence they appeared on screen. One later account says they did not appear in either film, while another says their appearance in The Thundering Herd remains unknown.6,7,9,10

Why did the bison stay?

Once the filming plans were over, the bison were left on Catalina. One account says there were limited means to remove and wrangle them; another describes returning them as too costly and troublesome. The sources do not establish one definitive reason, but both point to the difficulty of transporting and handling the animals.5,10

William Wrigley Jr., who owned Catalina Island, allowed the animals to remain. A later account says he brought additional bison to the island to increase genetic variation; reports differ on the number and timing of later additions. Over time, the herd grew substantially, with estimates reaching more than 400 and, in some accounts, as many as 600.5,7,8,9

How the herd is managed

The bison are American bison, a North American species, rather than buffalo. They are introduced animals on Catalina, and their grazing can affect the island’s native vegetation. A study described in one account found that bison coats carried introduced plants, including fennel, which can disrupt native species.5,8

The Catalina Island Conservancy monitors and manages the herd. Its approaches have included sending bison to the mainland and using contraception to limit reproduction. The Conservancy has also worked with Indigenous communities on relocations to the Great Plains. Sources describe different herd sizes at different times, so an old population figure should not be treated as a current count.7,8,9,10

Management reflects a balance: keeping a bison herd while limiting pressure on Catalina’s ecology. One source says the Conservancy maintains a herd of no more than 150 animals, while studies and other reports give different estimates or recommended ranges. These figures describe different reports and periods, not necessarily the same count or target.5,8,10

Where visitors may see them

The bison roam freely, and visitors may see them from Catalina’s driving, hiking, and biking routes. The Catalina Island Conservancy also offers tours. The sources do not guarantee sightings, so treat the bison as wildlife rather than a scheduled attraction.10

For a visit, the useful context is that the herd is managed and its numbers have changed over time. The animals are descendants of bison brought to the island for a film project, not a native Catalina population.5,8,10

Questions

Why are there bison on Catalina Island?

A group of American bison was brought to the island in 1924 for possible use in a Western film. The animals were left on Catalina after the filming plans, and the herd grew over time.6,7,10

Were the bison in The Vanishing American?

No bison appear in the 1925 film. Whether they appeared in The Thundering Herd is uncertain: reports conflict, and the film reels are missing.6,7,8,10

How many bison first arrived?

Accounts disagree. Several report 14, while others give figures of 12, 15, or 16.5,6,7,8,9,10

Can visitors see bison on Catalina?

The bison roam freely and may be seen from driving, hiking, and biking routes. The Catalina Island Conservancy offers tours, though sightings are not guaranteed by the available information.10

On the Map

Sources

  1. Wikipedia, History of Santa Catalina Island
  2. en.wikipedia.org, Catalina Airport - Wikipedia
  3. catalinavacations.com, Middle Ranch Catalina Island
  4. ecatalina.com, Delicious Days on Catalina Island
  5. Catalina Island Bison
  6. BISON
  7. 14 bison came to Catalina for a movie. 100 years later, ...
  8. Catalina Island bison herd
  9. The quest to save the Hollywood bison
  10. Why Does Catalina Island Have Bison? - AMLI Residential

Written by Pimu Press from the sources above. Prices and hours change; check with operators before you go.